Renewable energy? Go fly a kite!

by The Crazy Colombian on February 7, 2008

in Reflection, The Environment

Note: If you have come here with the need to com­pare my orig­i­nal arti­cle to that of NucFlu­ens, you’re in for a sur­prise. I have taken some of NucFlu­ens improve­ments, and incor­po­rated them in this post. In the near future I plan to include an archival copy of the orig­i­nal arti­cle (no photo, head­ers, and orig­i­nal title) for those of you inter­ested in the nature of the improve­ments. If you want to see a copy of the old post, go here (link)

Dancing Kites

Image: Danc­ing Kites by coola­banana

In the topic of renew­able energy, there is a heated debate about whether solar, wind, and other environmentally-friendly tech­nolo­gies will ever pro­vide an alter­na­tive to coal-generated power. The key issue at stake is whether the renew­able sources pro­vide suf­fi­cient energy with enough reli­a­bil­ity to replace coal in the pro­vi­sion of ’base load’. In case you’re new to the topic, base load refers to the min­i­mum amount of energy required by our cities. It is the baseline-level required to ensure no parts of our cities and rural areas have a black­out. Think about it as the min­i­mum wage required by our elec­tric­ity needs.

Base load: A prob­lem for alter­na­tive energy sources

The prob­lem with base load is that we need to ensure our gen­er­a­tion facil­i­ties always pro­vide at least that amount of power into the grid. But the sun doesn’t always shine; and the wind doesn’t always blow. There are sev­eral arti­cles that explain in detail the prob­lem that this poses for the devel­op­ment of a sus­tain­able, renew­able energy gen­er­a­tion sys­tem (link). There is a team of sci­en­tists based on Cal­i­for­nia that believes there is an alter­na­tive. I found out about them via Robert Cringely, a pub­lished author & colum­nist who has been writ­ing on the Tech­nol­ogy field for over 20 years. In his weekly col­umn ’I Cringely’ of the 12 of Octo­ber 2007 (link) , Bob describes the approach that ’Makani Power’ (link) is taking.

Makani Power: Cre­at­ing a bet­ter future

The basic idea is sim­ple enough: They want to build a super-kite to be flown at stratos­pheric alti­tudes, where the wind always blows at high speed; and attach power-generating tur­bines to the kites. If they suc­ceed, the area required to gen­er­ate ’base load’ for the whole of the US will be entirely within their means, as it will be for many other coun­tries — Aus­tralia included.

Google: An unlikely ally

This is very excit­ing news for those of us wor­ried about global warm­ing; and it was fas­ci­nat­ing to read that of all the com­pa­nies that could have invested into Makani Power, it was an unlikely investor that took the plunge. Their name? Google

The con­cept is sim­ple; more than enought money has been pro­vided; there are tech­ni­cal experts that are lumi­nar­ies in the field; and the com­pany back­ing this new ven­ture is renowned for an unprece­dented level of suc­cess. The only remain­ing ques­tion is When will it be ready?

For our own sake, I hope the answer is some­time very soon!

StumbleUpon Toolbar Did you like this arti­cle? Stum­ble It!

RSS Subscribe for free

{ 1 trackback }

invest in new energy sources
06.02.08 at 11:43 pm

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Baekho 02.08.08 at 3:40 am

That’s amaz­ing :D

. 02.19.08 at 8:32 pm

Baekho,

thanks for your com­ment. It is truly an amaz­ing idea; I only believed it because it was reported by such a trust­wor­thy source (Bob Cringely)

By the way, I loved your exe­cu­tion of this arti­cle in NuncFlu­ens. Your use of images, and the slightly more pol­ished lan­guage made a very big dif­fer­ence to the arti­cle. Well done, mate!

pierre 02.21.08 at 7:15 pm

Just like you, I was stunned by this amaz­ing project. Even moreso because being a kite artist and designer myself an I have met Pete Lynn,one of the Makani engi­neers, on a cou­ple of occa­sions when he was younger, at kite fes­ti­vals were he was assist­ing his father Peter Lynn the most famous kite inven­tor and kite­flier of our generation.

With the back­ground Pete was raised in and his train­ing in engi­neer­ing, no won­der he has been able to develop him­self a great con­cept for har­vest­ing the wind’s energy using kites. Along with the other kite experts at Makani, Don Mon­tague and Saul Grif­fith him­self, and with all the other telented engi­neers in the team they have buid up, I just can­not find a rea­son why they wouldn’t suc­ceed.
(Except maybe because of thun­der­storms; what would hap­pen when a light­ning strikes the power line link­ing the kites to the ground?)

How long will it take? These guys obvi­u­osly do things fast, they take their ideas directly from the brain to the work­bench… They also already have enough fund­ing to do almost what­ever they want. For sure they’ll be much faster than the Ital­ians cur­rently devel­op­ping the Kite­gen project which is in my opin­ion bound to fail any­way.
How­ever, the winds are so wild up there that it isn’t going to be that easy.
My guess is that it could take eas­ily 5 years before a fullscale func­tion­nal pro­to­type is made and suc­cess­fully tested.
10 years before the sys­tem is imple­mented worldwide…

. 02.22.08 at 10:11 am

pierre,

Thanks for leav­ing such a com­pre­hen­sive com­ment. It must be very excit­ing to know some­one like Pete Lynn ‘in the flesh’, even if it was at an ear­lier time.

I con­cur with your assess­ment: This group of peo­ple has a very real chance of mak­ing a mas­sive dif­fer­ence. Although to some peo­ple 5–10 years may sound like an eter­nity, it is noth­ing when you think in the time scales that advances in Alter­na­tive energy sources / Cli­mate change have happened.

I was also unaware of the Kite­gen project (link); I found it very inter­est­ing to see the dif­fer­ence in ‘web site & con­tent rich­ness’ between the 2 projects. Maybe Makani has elected to devote every penny to the actual devel­op­ment project; whereas Kite­gen appears to have a more com­pre­hen­sive PR & Mar­ket­ing budget.

I will keep an eye on devel­op­ments and report back when some­thing excit­ing hap­pens. Thanks again for par­tic­i­pat­ing in the forum!

–The Crazy Colombian

scott wherritt 04.13.08 at 5:55 pm

we prob­a­bly will not find the per­fect energy source for a will some day oil will run out and all other forms of energy will be used up even water the bible sais our water will turn to blood mean­ing unus­able at the very least to drink prob­a­bly for fuel to also it sais with­out devine inter­ven­tion no flesh shall be saved at the point of devine inter­ven­tion we will begine to live in har­mony with god when adam and eve lived in har­mony all was pro­vided god tells us to rea­son things out take all scrip­tures us them for prov­ing and refov­ing to find the truth i do not believe he intended for us to fly kites to get the mas­sive amounts of energy we need on earth but you get an aaaaaaa+ for cre­ative think­ing keep up the good work scott w

The Crazy Colombian 04.14.08 at 9:24 am

Scott: Thanks for your com­ment. The lack of punc­tu­a­tion made it dif­fi­cult to under­stand your points, so I hope I didn’t miss any crit­i­cal issues you raised.

Thanks for the aaaaaa+ on cre­ativ­ity. I hope you keep vis­it­ing ‘Reflec­tions of a Crazy Colom­bian’. You may want to con­sider sub­scrib­ing via email or on an RSS reader (see links at the top-right of the web site)

Best wishes,

–The Crazy Colombian

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Previous post:

Next post: